Milk myths: does the “white miracle” really help you fall asleep?

The industry association speaks of a “white miracle”. And indeed, some milk stories are more in the realm of magic than in reality. A fact check on Milk Day:

1. Warm milk helps you fall asleep

Valuation: Scientifically not proven.

Facts: Grandma Hilde recommended it to the offspring, as did grandmother Emine: warm milk with honey before going to bed.

The Stiftung Warentest, however, rates the old home recipe as a “nice dream” that stems from the fact that milk contains tryptophan. This amino acid serves the body as a precursor for the hormone melatonin, which controls the sleep-wake cycle.

However, the amount of tryptophan in milk is comparatively low and the sleep-promoting effect of even higher-dose preparations is poorly documented.

In a 2020 meta-study, Japanese researchers evaluated various studies on the effects of milk and dairy products on sleep.

Their result: A balanced diet including dairy products can improve the quality of sleep. However, the significance of some evaluated studies was low, according to the researchers. And the fact that evening milk was an effective aid to falling asleep could not be proven in general by any study.

However, that doesn’t mean the nightcap is definitely useless.

Psychological effects are quite conceivable: milk and honey are reminiscent of security and childhood. The ritual of an evening milk as such can also have a calming effect.

2. Milk baths provide beauty

Valuation: Doubtful.

Facts: The economy uses the myth in many different ways and successfully: hotels offer baths in milk and honey, which, like that of Egypt’s legendary queen, are said to make the skin firm and radiantly beautiful.

Cosmetics relate their ingredients to substances that are said to have been used since ancient times and advertise accordingly with Cleopatra’s name or likeness.

There is hardly any actual evidence of their beauty, and even less of their bathing habits.

Fresh milk in the glass

krisanapong detraphiphat / gettyimages

One might think of the Hollywood image of Elizabeth Taylor as Cleopatra bathing in a milky broth when it comes to the secret of her beauty.

The Roman naturalist Pliny left a clue to the actual extravagance when he related in the first century AD that the emperor’s wife Poppaea always carried 500 pregnant donkeys with her, in whose milk she bathed.

In translations there is also talk of mare or sheep’s milk. Since beauty can hardly be evaluated objectively, the secret remains exactly that – a secret.

3. Hippopotamus milk is pink

Valuation: Not correct.

Facts: It is one of the popular urban legends of the internet, which almost everyone has stumbled upon at some point: the allegedly uniquely colored hippo mother’s milk.

Even the renowned magazine “National Geographic” spread the claim on Facebook in 2013 as “Friday Fact”. In fact, the hippos do not feed on strawberry milk.

The American fact check portal “Snopes” has investigated the claim and comes to the verdict: That’s not true. The rumor may be that hippos excrete a reddish, sweat-like hipposudoric acid that protects their skin from the sun’s rays.

If this mixed with the white of breast milk, a pink-colored substance might result.

However, British biologist David Wynick cautions: “Because the pigment is acidic, I would assume it wouldn’t bond well with milk.” thereby turning pink.

A video released by the Cincinnati Zoo showing nurses milking a hippopotamus also shows no evidence of breast milk coloring.

hide sources

author

German Press Agency (dpa)

Sources

Stiftung Warentest for sleeping aid milk https://www.test.de/Abklopft-Hilft-heisse-Milch-mit-Honig-beim-Einschlafen-5520420-0/

All information about the dpa fact checks https://www.dpa.com/de/unternehmen/faktencheck/

Contact page for the dpa fact check team https://www.dpa.com/index.php?id=1384&ADMCMD_editIcons=1#kontakt

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.